The Battle of Fornham: When a Countess Rode to War and Changed Medieval England Forever
How a Suffolk swamp became the graveyard of rebellion and the unlikely stage for one of medieval England's most extraordinary warrior women.
Petronilla, the Ear of Leicester's wife, turned up for battle fully armoured in mail and equipped with shield and lance
In the mist-shrouded dawn of October 17, 1173, near the quiet Suffolk village of Fornham St. Genevieve, history was about to witness something remarkable. Not just another medieval battle between king and rebels, but the extraordinary tale of a countess who donned armor, took up lance and shield, and rode into battle alongside her husband against the Crown itself.
This is the story of Petronilla de Grandmesnil, Countess of Leicester – a woman whose courage would echo through the centuries, and whose fall into a muddy ditch would become one of the most memorable moments of medieval English warfare.
Subscribe for news on Rachel’s novels and short stories about strong medieval woman defying the conventions, and the men, of their time.
The Angevin Empire in Crisis
The year 1173 found Henry II's vast Angevin Empire convulsing in civil war. The Battle of Fornham was part of the revolt of 1173-4 which was sparked by a family feud between Henry II on one side and his wife - the formidable Eleanor of Aquitaine - and sons on the other. This wasn't merely a political uprising – it was a family at war with itself, tearing apart an empire that stretched from Scotland to the Pyrenees.
At the heart of this rebellion stood Robert de Beaumont, 3rd Earl of Leicester, a man caught between loyalty and ambition. Leicester had once been Henry II's trusted ally, but the king's increasingly autocratic rule and the influence of Eleanor of Aquitaine had turned friend into foe. When Henry's own sons – Henry the Young King, Richard, and Geoffrey – rose against their father, Leicester saw his moment.
But Leicester was not alone in his defiance. By his side stood his remarkable wife, Petronilla de Grandmesnil. In an age when noble ladies were expected to manage estates and bear heirs, Petronilla would choose a different path entirely – one that led directly onto the battlefield.
The Warrior Countess Emerges
Petronilla de Grandmesnil was no ordinary medieval noblewoman. Born into the powerful de Grandmesnil family, she possessed not only noble blood but an iron will that would soon be tested in the crucible of war. When her husband committed to rebellion against Henry II, Petronilla made a decision that shocked medieval society: she would fight beside him.
Leicester was captured, as was his wife, Petronilla de Grandmesnil, who had put on armour herself. Petronilla, Leicester's wife, who turned up for battle fully armoured in mail and equipped with shield and lance – this was unprecedented. Medieval warfare was a man's domain, yet here was a countess preparing for battle with the same dedication as any knight.
The Invasion Begins
October 1173 saw the revolt reach our Suffolk borders. Robert de Beaumont, 3rd Earl of Leicester, invaded England with an army of Flemish mercenaries, landing at Walton, Suffolk. Leicester took his forces to Framlingham where he joined Hugh Bigod, 1st Earl of Norfolk.
The plan seemed sound: Leicester would bring professional Flemish mercenaries – battle-hardened soldiers who fought for coin rather than feudal obligation. These warriors had earned fearsome reputations across Europe, and Leicester believed they would tip the balance against Henry II's forces.
Hugh Bigod, 1st Earl of Norfolk, became Leicester's crucial ally. Bigod controlled the powerful fortress of Framlingham and commanded significant local support. Together, they represented a formidable threat to royal authority in East Anglia.
The Royal Response
Henry II was in Normandy, but his absence didn't mean England was defenseless. The king had left capable lieutenants: Richard de Lucy, the Chief Justiciar, effectively the kingdom's prime minister, and Humphrey de Bohun, the Lord High Constable. These weren't court functionaries but seasoned military commanders who understood the existential threat Leicester's invasion posed.
The battle was fought on 17 October 1173 between rebel forces, under the command of Leicester, and royal forces, under the command of Richard de Lucy, the Chief Justiciar, as well as Humphrey de Bohun Lord High Constable; Reginald de Dunstanville, the Earl of Cornwall; William of Gloucester – Henry's loyalists were rallying.
An army of about 1500 men was mustered at Bury St Edmunds and marched out of the North and Risby gates towards Fornham Bridge to set up position probably on the high ground near the road leading to Barton. The royal forces had chosen their ground well – the high ground near Fornham, controlling the approaches to Bury St Edmunds.
The Fateful March
Leicester faced a critical decision. His original plan had been to avoid major confrontation and march swiftly to his stronghold at Leicester Castle. But the Earl of Leicester, wanting to avoid Bury travelled cross-county heading for his castle at Leicester. He approached Fornham with the large force of mercenaries. It is thought that floods on the River Lark caused him to eventually accept battle at Fornham in October 1173.
Nature itself seemed to conspire against the rebels. The River Lark, swollen with autumn rains, had flooded the surrounding countryside, channeling Leicester's army toward the very confrontation he had hoped to avoid. The hero's journey had reached its darkest moment – the ordeal was about to begin.
Petronilla's Moment of Truth
As Leicester's army approached Fornham, Petronilla faced her own moment of truth. She could have remained with the baggage train, safe from the immediate danger of battle. Instead, she made the extraordinary decision that would define her place in history.
The Countess of Leicester armed herself for war. She donned a hauberk – a shirt of mail that could weigh thirty pounds or more. She took up a shield bearing her family's arms and grasped a lance, the primary weapon of medieval cavalry. In doing so, she transformed from a noble lady into something medieval Europe had rarely seen: a warrior countess ready to charge into battle.
The Battle Unfolds
The Battle of Fornham St Genevieve, 1173.
The Battle of Fornham began as Leicester had hoped – his Flemish mercenaries, despite being outnumbered, initially held their ground against the royal forces. These professional soldiers had fought across Europe and were not easily intimidated by English knights.
But Richard de Lucy had prepared a tactical masterstroke. Rather than meeting Leicester's army head-on, he had positioned his forces to take advantage of the flooded terrain. With his forces split, Leicester's cavalry was captured and his mercenaries were driven into nearby swamps where the local peasants killed most of them.
The battle became a rout. Leicester's professional mercenaries, so confident on solid ground, found themselves floundering in marshland where their weapons and training meant little. Worse still, the local peasants – loyal to Henry II or simply protective of their lands – turned on the struggling mercenaries.
Petronilla's Fall and Capture
In the chaos of defeat, Petronilla's moment of legendary status arrived in the most unexpected way. Petronilla, Leicester's wife, who turned up for battle fully armoured in mail and equipped with shield and lance, fell into a ditch, lost her rings, and was pulled out by Simon of Odell with the words, according to Jordan Fantosme, "My Lady, come away from this place, and abandon your design!
This moment – a warrior countess tumbling into a muddy ditch during the rout – might seem comical, but it represents something profound. Petronilla had crossed every boundary medieval society placed on noblewomen. She had donned armor, taken up arms, and ridden into battle. Her fall into the ditch wasn't just physical; it marked the end of one of the most extraordinary individual acts of courage in medieval English history.
Simon of Odell, the man who pulled her from the ditch, was likely a royal knight who recognized the historical significance of capturing such a remarkable prisoner. His words to her – recorded by the contemporary chronicler Jordan Fantosme – show a mixture of respect and urgency. Even in defeat, Petronilla commanded admiration.
The Aftermath
Leicester remained in captivity until Henry II chose to release him, but both Leicester and Petronilla had been fundamentally changed by their experience at Fornham. The rebellion that had promised to reshape England had been crushed in a single afternoon, but its participants had achieved a different kind of immortality.
For Petronilla, capture meant the end of her brief career as a warrior, but the beginning of her legend. Medieval chroniclers, who typically ignored women unless they were queens or saints, couldn't resist recording the story of the countess who fought at Fornham. Her courage had transcended the boundaries of her time and gender.
The Broader Impact
The Battle of Fornham effectively ended the rebellion in England, though fighting would continue elsewhere in Henry II's domains. The defeat of Leicester's invasion force sent a clear message: Henry II's administrative and military systems were robust enough to function even in his absence.
The use of Flemish mercenaries, which had seemed so promising to Leicester, had backfired spectacularly. Their defeat at Fornham demonstrated that foreign mercenaries, however skilled, were vulnerable when fighting on unfamiliar terrain without local support.
More significantly, the battle showed the importance of choosing one's ground. Richard de Lucy's decision to force battle near the flooded River Lark had been tactically brilliant, turning Leicester's professional soldiers into helpless targets.
Reconciliation
Leicester and Petronilla's story didn't end at Fornham. Though captured and imprisoned, they would eventually be released and reconciled with Henry II. This was typical of medieval politics – today's rebel could be tomorrow's ally, and Henry II was pragmatic enough to prefer former enemies as friends rather than martyrs.
Leicester would live to serve Henry II again, his rebellion forgotten in favor of renewed loyalty. But Petronilla's story had transcended the political moment. She had become something unique in medieval history: a woman who had claimed the right to fight alongside men, not as an exception granted by circumstance, but as a choice made from courage and conviction.
Legacy: The Warrior Countess Lives On
Historical Significance
The Battle of Fornham represents more than just another medieval conflict. It stands as a pivotal moment in the consolidation of Henry II's empire and a fascinating glimpse into the lives of extraordinary individuals who shaped their times.
Richard de Lucy's victory demonstrated the effectiveness of Henry II's governmental system. Even with the king absent in Normandy, his officials could mobilize armies, coordinate strategy, and win decisive battles. This administrative competence would be crucial to the Angevin Empire's survival.
Petronilla's Enduring Impact
But perhaps the most enduring legacy of Fornham belongs to Petronilla de Grandmesnil. In an age when women's roles were strictly circumscribed, she had chosen to be a warrior. Her story resonates across the centuries because it speaks to universal themes of courage, loyalty, and the refusal to accept limitations.
Medieval chroniclers preserved her story precisely because it was so unusual. In doing so, they ensured that future generations would know that among the knights and mercenaries at Fornham, there rode a countess who had claimed her place in the ranks of warriors.
Modern Remembrance
Today, the battlefield at Fornham St. Genevieve is quiet farmland, but historians and enthusiasts work to preserve the memory of what happened there. The story of Petronilla, Leicester, and the battle that changed their lives continues to fascinate anyone interested in medieval history, women's history, or simply extraordinary tales of human courage.
The Battle of Fornham reminds us that history is made not just by kings and kingdoms, but by individuals who choose to step beyond the ordinary boundaries of their time. In October 1173, on a flooded battlefield in Suffolk, a countess made that choice – and in doing so, claimed her place in the eternal story of human courage and determination.